5 Stars from the Last 5 NFL Drafts to be Passed Up for Busts

5 Stars from the Last 5 NFL Drafts to be Passed Up for Busts

Many NFL stars over the past 5 years have been drafted much later than players who wound up being busts. Here are some of the biggest stars who have been passed up from the 2014-2019 NFL Drafts.

Jarvis Landry (2014, Pick 63, MIA)

Jarvis Landry has played second fiddle to Odell Beckham Jr. throughout his football career, and the 2014 NFL Draft was no different. While Beckham was drafted by the Giants at the 12th overall pick behind Sammy Watkins and Mike Evans, Landry fell all the way to the second to last pick of the second round of the draft.

View this post on Instagram

No dream is out of reach…. 🐺

A post shared by Jarvis Landry (@juice_landry) on

The 2014 wide receiver class was a fantastic one, including the four aforementioned receivers along with Davante Adams, but Landry fell way further on the draft board than he should have. While he was arguably the third-best receiver in his class, Landry was the 9th wide receiver taken in the NFL Draft. One of the best receivers in the league today was taken behind forgetful receivers like Marqise Lee and Jordan Matthews. The Dolphins got a true steal in Jarvis Landry.

 Tyreek Hill (2016, Pick 165, KC)

My jaw dropped when I found out that Tyreek Hill was picked in the second half of the 5th round in the 2016 NFL Draft. One of the fastest players and best receivers in the league was drafted way later than he should have been. Though he is by far the second most successful wide receiver from the 2016 NFL Draft, Hill was the 18th selected receiver.. Hill was picked after players even the most avid football watchers don’t remember, such as Leonte Carroo, Ricardo Louis, and Braxton Miller

The only other receiver from this draft that was better than Hill is Michael Thomas. Thomas was surprisingly picked sixth among wide receivers when he definitely should have been the first drafted among wide receivers. The 2016 draft was riddled with busts in the receiver category, but both the Saints and Chiefs got gems in Thomas and Hill.

Patrick Mahomes II (2017, Pick 10, KC)

One could not click on this article without knowing the Patrick Mahomes/Mitchell Trubisky debacle would be mentioned. The biggest of many mistakes the Chicago Bears have made over the past few years is draft Mitchell Trubisky over Patrick Mahomes. 

View this post on Instagram

Game Face!! 🤣🤣

A post shared by Patrick Mahomes II (@patrickmahomes) on

RELATED: Is The NFL Season Getting Pushed Back?

These last two years, Mahomes has been the League MVP and Super Bowl MVP and has established himself as the best passer in the league. Meanwhile, Trubisky has thrown 48 Touchdowns and a shameful 29 interceptions. The Bears missed a generational talent in Mahomes who will pay dividends for the Chiefs in the years to come. 

Lamar Jackson (2018, Pick 32, BAL)

It seems every time in a primetime game featuring the Ravens the commentators will mention at least once how Lamar Jackson was the fifth quarterback picked in the first round of the 2018 NFL Draft. Things seemed grim fo Jackson’s first-round hopes when the Eagles were on the clock with the final pick of night one of the draft. Out of nowhere, the Ravens picked up Joe Flacco’s successor, Jackson, surprising fans from Baltimore and across the whole country.


Jackson would be retiring general manager, Ozzie Newsome’s parting gift to the Ravens, as the young quarterback has a regular-season record of 19-3 and became the 2019 NFL MVP.

Though they are not all bad, the four quarterbacks taken before Jackson are definitely inferior to the Florida native. Josh Allen is actually a pretty adept passer who has a bright future with the Bills ahead of him. Baker Mayfield has his moments, but he should be considered okay at best and mediocre at worst. Sam Darnold hasn’t seen the field much due to various injuries, but he hasn’t quite shined when he has been healthy. Meanwhile, Josh Rosen is practically out of the league after being replaced by Kyler Murray in Arizona and then again by Tua Tagovailoa in Miami. 

Lamar definitely has a college-style of play that many were unsure would translate to the NFL. Still, it is hard to believe the reigning NFL MVP was only the fifth picked quarterback in his draft class.

JuJu Smith-Schuster (2017, Pick 62, PIT)

JuJu Smith-Schuster is one of the most electrifying and entertaining wide receivers in the league today, so many NFL fans are surprised when they find out Smith-Schuster was taken at the end of the second round of the 2017 NFL Draft.

The 2017 receiving class was very underwhelming, as the only receivers of note in the draft were JuJu Smith-Schuster, Kenny Golladay, and Chris Godwin. Smith-Schuster was the first of the three to be picked, yet he was the fifth wide receiver picked in the draft. The only receivers who went before Smith-Schuster who are worth mentioning are Titans’ wide receiver, Corey Davis, and Bengals’ receiver, John Ross. The Steelers are lucky they drafted Smith-Schuster in 2017, as he was bringing life to a dwindling Pittsburgh offense in 2019.

About At The Buzzer

At The Buzzer, or ATB, is the place for those who love sports, life, family, community, and so much more. We are far from the run of the mill 24/7 sports news websites. We not only bring you what’s happening in the world of sports in terms of trades and breaking news, but we also bring you the news that goes on behind the scenes. The stuff you don’t see during the 48 minutes of an NBA game or the 60 minutes of an NFL game. We let you know what’s going on in the lives of your favorite athletes. From big life moments like becoming a mother or a father to highlighting personal videos of them raising their little ones, At The Buzzer is the place you go when you want to relate to the athlete you root for on a daily basis. If you're interested in how Russell Wilson juggles being one of the best quarterbacks in the league while also being a doting husband and father-of-three, we got you covered. Interested in seeing a video of Iman Shupert's three-month-old baby speaking her first words, we have that here at ATB. Or would you rather watch Tiger Woods' son growing up and following in his father's footsteps, don't worry, we can show you that too. At The Buzzer is so much more than sports. It's relatable, reliable, and ready to show you a side of sports you didn't know existed. Our goal at ATB is to bring you relatable, entertaining news that will leave you feeling closer and more informed about the people you are looking up to and rooting for. Sports are more than just a group of organizations that entertain you, it's about the people who make up those organizations and the stories of how they became the people they are today. So take a minute and read one of our articles, we promise you won't regret it.

1 thought on “5 Stars from the Last 5 NFL Drafts to be Passed Up for Busts”

  1. Pingback: Who Will Win the NFC South This Year?

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: