25 Best American Hockey Players of All-Time

25 Best American Hockey Players of All-Time

The best American hockey players of all-time will forever be remembered for their efforts on the ice. They represented their country better than anyone else, proved they belonged in the best league in the world, and will go down as some of the greatest players to ever skate in the NHL. 

Although the NHL is largely based in the United States, a strong majority of players in the league weren’t born in the United States. For example, only 186 active and current NHL players were born in the United States — which is just over 25% of all NHL players in the league today. 

And that’s largely been the case over the history of the NHL. It’s a sport that’s largely been dominated by foreign players, but that doesn’t mean the United States hasn’t produced its fair share of great players. In fact, the US has produced some of the most revered NHL players. 

RELATED: Top 25 All-Time Fastest Skaters in the NHL

Who Are the Best American Hockey Players Ever?

25 Best American Hockey Players of All-Time
Photo Works / Shutterstock

Every now and then, we witness an American-born player enter the NHL and put the league on notice with their skill, talent, leadership, intelligence, and complete dominance. These players are usually the ones we see representing Team USA at the Olympics every four years. 

They bring honor and respect to the country they call home and embody everything this country is built on. With all the foreign players who have showcased their skill in the NHL, it’s the best American hockey players that will forever hold a special place in the hearts of American fans.

When you think of the best American hockey players ever, there are probably a few names that come to mind immediately — don’t worry, we’re all thinking of the same people. In fact, we’re going to list out 25 best American hockey players of all-time — so let’s get started! 

25. RW Phil Kessel

Birthplace: Madison, Wisconsin

Seasons: 2006-present (16 seasons)

Teams: Boston Bruins, Toronto Maple Leafs, Pittsburgh Penguins, Arizona Coyotes

Career Stats: 1,127 games, 391 goals, 516 assists, 907 points, 247 blocked shots, 19:45 average time on ice

Phil Kessel was drafted fifth overall by the Boston Bruins in 2006 and made his debut that same season. He has been as consistent as anyone over the past 13 years, scoring more than 20 goals in 12 of those seasons and above 30 goals in six of them. He’s also a two-time champion.

24. G Tom Barrasso

Birthplace: Boston, Massachusetts

Seasons: 1983-2003 (19 seasons)

Teams: Pittsburgh Penguins, Buffalo Sabres, Ottawa Senators, Carolina Hurricanes, toronto Maple Leafs, St. Louis Blues

Career Stats: 777 games, 369-277-86 record, 19,695 saves, .892 save percentage, 3.24 goals against average 

Tom Barrasso was drafted by the Buffalo Sabres with the fifth overall pick in 1983. He made an immediate impact on the team, winning more than 20 games in four of his first five seasons in the NHL. He went on to do that 11 times in his career, including a career-high 43 wins in 1992.

23. RW T.J. Oshie

Birthplace: Everett, Washington

Seasons: 2008-present (14 seasons)

Teams: St. Louis Blues, Washington Capitals

Career Stats: 861 games, 261 goals, 351 assists, 612 points, 597 blocks, 18:32 average time on ice

T.J. Oshie was drafted by the St. Louis Blues with the 24th overall pick of the 2005 draft, but didn’t make his first start until the 2008-09 season. He scored 70 goals in his first five seasons and more than 20 goals in six of the last eight seasons — including a career-high 33 in 2016. 

22. G Ryan Miller

Birthplace: East Lansing, Michigan

Seasons: 2002-2021 (18 seasons)

Teams: Buffalo Sabres, Anaheim Ducks, Vancouver Canucks, St. Louis Blues

Career Stats: 796 games, 391-289-88 record, 21,665 saves, .914 save percentage, 2.64 goals against average

Ryan Miller was drafted by the Buffalo Sabres in the fifth round of the 1999 draft and made his debut in 2002. His .914 save percentage ranks ninth among American goalies, but his 391 wins ranks first. He won 40+ games in two different seasons, including a career-high 41 wins in 2009

21. C Mark Johnson

Birthplace: Minneapolis, Minnesota

Seasons: 1979-1990 (11 seasons)

Teams: New Jersey Devils, Pittsburgh Penguins, Hartford Whalers, Minnesota North Stars, St. Louis Blues

Career Stats: 669 games, 203 goals, 305 assists, 508 points, 19 game-winning shots, 658 shots on goal

Mark Johnson was a fourth round draft pick by the Pittsburgh Penguins in 1977 and made his debut during the 1979 season. He helped lead Team USA to a Gold medal in 1980 and was one of the star players during the ‘Miracle on Ice’ game. He scored a career-high 35 goals in 1983

20. D Mark Howe

Birthplace: Detroit, Michigan

Seasons: 1979-1995 (16 seasons)

Teams: Hartford Whalers, Philadelphia Flyers, Detroit Red Wings

Career Stats: 929 games, 197 goals, 545 assists, 742 points, 23 game winning goals, 2,132 shots

Six years prior to joining the NHL, Mark Howe was lighting up the World Hockey Association (WHA) from 1973-1979. He scored 208 goals over that span as a defender. He would carry that success over into the NHL, scoring the 30th-most points by an American-born NHL player. 

19. D John Carlson

Birthplace: Natick, Massachusetts

Seasons: 2009-present (13 seasons)

Teams: Washington Capitals

Career Stats: 814 games, 115 goals, 409 assists, 524 points, 1,575 blocks, 23:24 average time on ice

John Carlson was selected 27th overall by the Washington Capitals in 2008 and made his debut the following season. He led the league in points by a defenseman in 2017 and 2019, and has been in the top-five the past four years. He recorded a career-high 60 assists in 2019

18. RW Joe Pavelski

Birthplace: Plover, Wisconsin

Seasons: 2006-present (16 seasons)

Teams: San Jose Sharks, Dallas Stars

Career Stats: 1,091 games, 395 goals, 450 assists, 845 points, 809 blocks, 18:53 average time on ice

Joe Pavelski is as consistent as they come, scoring more than 20 goals 11 times out of the past 15 years — including more than 30 goals four times and a career-high 41 goals in 2013. He makes the most of his minutes and currently has the 16th most points by an American player.

17. RW Tony Amonte

Birthplace: Hingham, Massachusetts

Seasons: 1991-2007 (15 seasons)

Teams: Chicago Blackhawks, Philadelphia Flyers, New York Rangers, Calgary Flames, Phoenix Coyotes

Career Stats: 1,174 games, 416 goals, 484 assists, 900 points, 58 game winning goals, 3,260 shots

Tony Amonte was drafted in the fourth round in 1988, which was a steal considering he scored 35 goals in his rookie year (1991) and 33 goals in his sophomore season. He would go on to score more than 30 goals in eight different seasons, including more than 40 goals three times. 

16. G Mike Richter

Birthplace: Abington, Pennsylvania

Seasons: 1989-2003 (14 seasons)

Teams: New York Rangers

Career Stats: 666 games, 301-258-73 record, 17,379 saves, .904 save percentage, 2.89 goals against average

Mike Richter is one of five American goalies to record more than 300 wins in their career. His .904 save percentage and 2.89 goals against average rank in the top-35 among American goalies. The second round draft pick spent his entire 14-year career with the New York Rangers.

15. RW Bill Guerrin

Birthplace: Worcester, Massachusetts

Seasons: 1991-2010 (18 seasons)

Teams: New Jersey Devils, Edmonton Oilers, Dallas Stars, Boston Bruins, New York Islanders, Pittsburgh Penguins, San Jose Sharks, St. Louis Blues

Career Stats: 1,263 games, 429 goals, 427 assists, 856 points, 77 game-winning goals, 3,693 shots

Bill Guerin was drafted fifth overall by the New Jersey Devils in 1989 and made his debut three seasons later. After a slow start to his career, he would eventually score more than 40 goals in back-to-back years from 2000-2002. His 429 goals ranks seventh among American players.

14. C Neal Broten

Birthplace: Roseau, Minnesota

Seasons: 1980-1997 (17 seasons)

Teams: Minnesota North Stars, Dallas Stars, New Jersey Devils, Los Angeles Kings

Career Stats: 1,099 games, 289 goals, 684 assists, 923 points, 34 game-winning goals, 2,313 shots

Neal Broten was drafted in the second round in 1979 and made his NHL debut the following season. He wouldn’t see regular playing time until 1981 and made the most of it, scoring a career-high 38 goals that season. His 634 career assists ranks 10th among American players. 

13. G Frank Brimsek

Birthplace: Eveleth, Minnesota

Seasons: 1938-1950 (10 seasons)

Teams: Boston Bruins, Chicago Blackhawks

Career Stats: 514 games, 252-182-80 record, 40 shutouts, 1,403 goals against, 2.70 goals against average

Frank Brimsek is a Hall of Fame goalie, two-time Stanley Cup winner, eight-time All-Star, two-time Vezina Trophy winner, and also won the Calder Memorial Trophy. He won 64 games in his first two years in the league and had 252 career wins, despite only playing 10 seasons.

12. RW Joe Mullen

Birthplace: New York, New York

Seasons: 1981-1997 (16 seasons)

Teams: Pittsburgh Penguins, St. Louis Blues, Calgary Flames, Boston Bruins

Career Stats: 1,062 games, 502 goals, 561 assists, 1,063 points, 73 game-winning goals, 2,787 shots

Joe Mullen was inducted in the Hall of Fame in 2000 following an illustrious career, which included three Stanley Cup championships and two Lady Byng Memorial Trophy wins. He’s one of five American players to score more than 500 goals and his 561 career assists ranks 13th.  

11. LW Keith Tkachuk

Birthplace: Melrose, Massachusetts

Seasons: 1991-2010 (18 seasons)

Teams: Phoenix Coyotes, Winnipeg Jets, St. Louis Blues, Atlanta Thrashers

Career Stats: 1,201 games, 538 goals, 527 assists, 1,065 points, 72 game-winning goals, 3,530 shots

Keith Tkachuk was drafted by the Winnipeg Jets with the 27th overall pick in 1990. He scored 94 goals in his first four years in the NHL, but followed that up with 50 goals in 1995 and a career-high 52 goals in 1996. His 538 goals ranks third among American-born NHL players. 

10. G Jonathan Quick

Birthplace: Milford, Connecticut

Seasons: 2007-present (15 seasons)

Teams: Los Angeles Kings

Career Stats: 669 games, 336-251-70 record, 16,400 saves, .913 save percentage, 2.41 goals against average

Jonathan Quick was a third round draft choice for the Los Angeles Kings and has proved to be a valuable one — spending his entire 15-year career with the team thus far. He won 33 or more games six times in his career and his 336 career wins ranks fourth among American goalies.

9. C Jeremy Roenick 

Birthplace: Boston Massachusetts

Seasons: 1988-2009 (20 seasons)

Teams: Chicago Blackhawks, Phoenix Coyotes, Philadelphia Flyers, San Jose Sharks, Los Angeles Kings

Career Stats: 1,363 games, 513 goals, 703 assists, 1,216 points, 92 game-winning goals, 3,281 shots

Jeremy Roenick is one of five American players to score more than 500 goals, one of six American players to record more than 700 assists, and his 1,216 career points ranks fourth among American players. He scored 50+ goals in back-to-back seasons in 1991 and 1992.

8. D Brian Leetch

Birthplace: Corpus Christi, Texas

Seasons: 1987-2006 (18 seasons)

Teams: New York Rangers, Toronto Maple Leafs, Boston Bruins

Career Stats: 1,205 games, 247 goals, 781 assists, 1,028 points, 38 game-winning goals, 3,640 shots

Brian Leetch was the Rangers’ ninth overall draft choice in 1986 and it paid off. He scored more than 20 goals four times in his career and more than 50 assists six times. His 781 assists ranks third among American players and he’s one of ten American players with 1,000+ points.

7. C Jack Eichel

Birthplace: North Chelmsford, Massachusetts

Seasons: 2015-present (6 seasons)

Teams: Buffalo Sabres

Career Stats: 375 games, 139 goals, 216 assists, 355 points, 25 game-winning goals, 1,324 shots, 203 blocks, 20:19 average time on ice

Jack Eichel hasn’t been in the league very long, but has proven to be one of the most talented players in the game right now. He has never scored less than 24 goals in a full season and is nearly averaging a point per game. If he’s traded anytime soon, his numbers should improve. 

6. C Auston Matthews

Birthplace: San Ramon, California

Seasons: 2016-present (6 seasons)

Teams: Toronto Maple Leafs

Career Stats: 338 games, 200 goals, 152 assists, 352 points, 35 game-winning goals, 1,248 shots, 290 blocks, 19:15 average time on ice

Auston Matthews is off to one of the best starts to his career the NHL has ever seen. Despite only being in the league six years, he has already scored 200 career goals and 152 assists. Through his first five years, he scored more than 40 goals three times, including 47 in 2019.

5. D Phil Housley

Birthplace: St. Paul, Minnesota

Seasons: 1982-2003 (21 seasons)

Teams: Buffalo Sabres, Calgary Flames, Washington Capitals, Winnipeg Jets, Chicago Blackhawks, St. Louis Blues, New Jersey Devils, Toronto Maple Leafs

Career Stats: 1,495 games, 338 goals, 894 assists, 1,232 points, 49 game-winning goals, 3,808 shots

No American player has ever recorded more career assists than Phil Housley. The former sixth overall pick scored more than 20 goals in seven different seasons and more than 40 assists in 13 different seasons. He currently has the third-most career points among American players.

4. D Chris Chelios

Birthplace: Chicago, Illinois

Seasons: 1983-2010 (26 seasons)

Teams: Detroit Red Wings, Chicago Blackhawks, Montreal Canadiens, Atlanta Thrashers

Career Stats: 1,651 games, 185 goals, 763 assists, 948 points, 31 game-winning goals, 3,627 shots

No American player has played more games in their career than Chris Chelios — who played 1,651 games in a 26-year career. In fact, that number ranks eighth among all NHL players. He didn’t score often (185 goals), but his 763 career assists ranks fourth among American players.

3. RW  Patrick Kane

Birthplace: Buffalo, New York

Seasons: 2007-present (15 seasons)

Teams: Chicago Blackhawks

Career Stats: 1,034 games, 405 goals, 688 assists, 1,093 points, 65 game-winning goals, 3,421 shots, 217 blocks, 20:12 average time on ice

Patrick Kane helped the Chicago Blackhawks return to dominance, winning the Stanley Cup three times in his 15-year career. He has been one of the most consistent players in the league, scoring more than 20 goals from 2007-2019 — including a career-high 46 goals in 2015-16.

2. C Pat LaFontaine

Birthplace: St. Louis, Missouri

Seasons: 1983-1998 (15 seasons)

Teams: New York Islanders, Buffalo Sabres, New York Rangers

Career Stats: 865 games, 468 goals, 545 assists, 1,013 points, 59 game-winning goals, 2,664 shots

Pat LaFontaine was the third overall pick by the Islanders in 1983. He scored more than 40 goals in six straight seasons from 1987-1992, scoring 286 goals over that time. His 468 career goals ranks sixth among Americans and he’s one of ten Americans with more than 1,000 points. 

1. C Mike Modano

Birthplace: Livonia, Michigan

Seasons: 1989-2011 (21 seasons)

Teams: Minnesota North Stars, Dallas Stars, Detroit Red Wings

Career Stats: 1,499 games, 561 goals, 813 assists, 1,374 points, 92 game-winning goals, 4,273 shots

Mike Modano was the first overall pick by the Minnesota North Stars in 1988 and he proved why, becoming one of the best American hockey players of all-time. He ranks second among American players in goals, assists, and points. He scored a career-high 50 goals in 1993-94.

Who Are the Best American Hockey Players Right Now?

Of the 25 best American hockey players listed above, seven of them were born in the state of Massachusetts. The only other states with multiple players are Minnesota with four players, Michigan with three players, and New York and Wisconsin both have two players. 

That means 18 of the 25 best American hockey players were born in one of four states — which is incredible to think about. In fact, those same four states continue to produce some of the best American hockey players in the league right now and have some of the best hockey colleges. 

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: The 25 Best Hockey Players of All-Time

We mentioned some of the best American hockey players in the NHL right now in the list above — including Eichel, Matthews, Kane, Quick, Pavelski, Carlson, Oshie, and Kessel. 

Some of the other best American hockey players right now include Quinn Hughes, Connor Hellebuyck, Johnny Gaudreau, Matthew Tkachuk, Kyle Connor, Blake Wheeler, Max Pacioretty, Paul Stastny, and Zach Parise

About At The Buzzer

At The Buzzer, or ATB is the place for those who love sports, life, family, community, and so much more. We are far from the run-of-the-mill 24/7 sports news websites. We not only bring you what’s happening in the world of sports in terms of trades and breaking news, but we also bring you the news that goes on behind the scenes, like big life moments, and so much more. So take a minute and read one of our articles, we promise you won't regret it.